The Daily Stoic · the podbrain notes ·
2 min read

It’s Not Only Always Been Like This, It’s Always Been Worse | Trust But Verify

Ryan Holiday hosts this Daily Stoic podcast episode focused on bringing stoic virtues into daily practice through examining our immediate reactions and assumptions.

The Daily Stoic The Daily Stoic
Subscribe to Notes Upgrade
The Daily Stoic episode thumbnail: It’s Not Only Always Been Like This, It’s Always Been Worse | Trust But Verify
The Daily Stoic
Key Takeaways
  1. 01

    "First off, don't let the force of an impression carry you away. Say to it, hold up a bit, let me see who you are" - Epictetus

  2. 02

    Modern problems aren't uniquely terrible - ancient civilizations faced earthquakes, tyrants, slavery, and systemic injustices that were often worse than today

  3. 03

    Blink demonstrates how rapid cognition can be both a strength for quick decisions and a weakness for confirming prejudices

  4. 04

    Therapeutic technique: preface assumptions with "what I make up about that is" to distinguish opinion from verifiable fact

  5. 05

    The obstacle becomes the way when you pause to reframe inconveniences as opportunities for different outcomes

  6. 06

    "Trust but verify" applies to gut instincts - initial reactions may be correct but warrant investigation before acting

Get the latest ideas from The Daily Stoic.

Plus the best new takeaways from other top podcasts — read in minutes, not hours.

or

By continuing, you agree to podbrain's Terms and Privacy Policy.

These notes may contain occasional inaccuracies. Learn how podbrain notes are made

Ryan Holiday hosts this Daily Stoic podcast episode focused on bringing stoic virtues into daily practice through examining our immediate reactions and assumptions.

The episode centers on a quote from Epictetus's Discourses about testing impressions before being carried away by them, connecting this ancient wisdom to modern cognitive science from Blink by Malcolm Gladwell.

Holiday explores how the same mental quickness that enables good decision-making can also reinforce biases, and shares practical techniques from therapy for distinguishing assumptions from facts.

Historical Perspective on Modern Problems

Ancient civilizations faced worse challenges than today - earthquakes, tyrants, slavery, child labor in mines, and science experiments on minorities were common in Zeno and Marcus Aurelius's time.

"Even the people you disagree with and dislike politically are not selling their enemies into slavery, sending children to work in mines or doing science experiments on minorities" - Holiday

We live in unprecedented abundance of medicine, knowledge, and opportunity that ancient Stoics "could not have imagined in their wildest dreams."

The Double-Edged Nature of Quick Thinking

Blink by Malcolm Gladwell shows how we constantly make split-second decisions based on years of experience, but this same skill confirms prejudices and stereotypes.

Epictetus's Discourses (2.1.8) advises: "Don't let the force of an impression carry you away. Say to it, hold up a bit, let me see who you are, where you are from."

Stoics aren't emotionless - they're less immediately reactive because they stop, think, and question their initial impressions.

Practical Techniques for Testing Assumptions

Therapeutic technique: preface statements with "what I make up about that is" to distinguish opinion from verifiable fact.

Key questions to ask: "Is it really so bad? What do I really know about this person? Why do I have such strong feelings here?"

Real-time example: when Holiday's son interrupted the recording, he reframed the "inconvenience" as a second chance for bedtime, demonstrating the obstacle as opportunity principle.

Trust But Verify Your Gut Instincts

The Russian proverb "trust but verify" applies to gut reactions - sometimes initial instincts are correct, but verification is essential.

"Do you deserve to trust that gut? Have you done the work that warrants that?" - Holiday questions whether our instincts have earned reliability.

Email example: distinguishing between actual rude tone versus projecting your internal voice onto neutral text requires conscious examination.

The Daily Stoic
From The Daily Stoic. Get a note like this from every new episode.
Subscribe to Notes Upgrade

These notes may contain occasional inaccuracies. Learn how podbrain notes are made

0 / 0
Link copied